Nylas vs Cronofy in 2026: Calendar Sync, CASA & TCO
Nylas vs Cronofy vs Aurinko and owned Google Workspace + Microsoft Graph sync in 2026: public per-account pricing, which Google scopes need CASA Tier 2, a PostgreSQL KMS token vault, and 36-month TCO math at 6,000 accounts.

On this page

Nylas vs Cronofy is the first fork most B2B SaaS teams hit when they add two-way calendar availability, interview panels, clinical booking or inbox features. Nylas is a unified email, calendar and contacts API. Cronofy is a calendar scheduling API. Behind them sit two more options: Aurinko, the cheapest of the common Nylas alternatives, and syncing Google Workspace and Microsoft Graph yourself. At 50 pilot users a per-account fee looks free. At 6,000 connected accounts, public list prices add up to roughly $161,000 to $378,000 in vendor fees over 36 months, before any engineering time.
Keep the layers separate. Resend vs Sendgrid covers outbound transactional email and Knock vs Novu covers cross-channel notification orchestration. This guide is about two-way sync of your users' calendars and mailboxes over OAuth, what it costs, and which Google scopes trigger a CASA Tier 2 assessment.
At Idealogic, our custom software development, SaaS development, software development consulting, and product development teams build scheduling systems for healthtech, real estate and PropTech, and fintech products. What follows is our 2026 comparison of Nylas v3, Cronofy, Aurinko and owned Google Calendar API sync, a PostgreSQL token vault with a 410 Gone recovery worker, and a 36-month TCO model at 6,000 accounts. Vendor prices are the public list prices we checked on November 14, 2026.
Which should you pick
- Nylas, if you need email, calendar and contacts behind one API and want to start self-serve.
- Cronofy, if scheduling logic is the product and you care which of six data centers holds the data.
The short version
- Nylas v3 replaced v2's hosted mailbox mirror with a thinner model that calls Google and Microsoft and caches about 90 days of messages. Nylas pricing on Pro annual is $43 a month plus $1.75 per extra email and calendar account, or $1.35 calendar-only.
- Cronofy pricing starts at $819 a month for 500 synced accounts (Emerging, billed annually). You're paying for multi-person and sequenced availability, embeddable UI elements, and ISO/IEC 27001 and SOC 2 hosting with a choice of six data centers.
- Aurinko syncs email, calendar, contacts and tasks across Google, Microsoft 365 and Exchange from $1.00 per account a month (under 1 GB of transfer).
- Owning Google Calendar incremental sync and Microsoft Graph
deltaLinkis a 560-hour build, $42,000 at our CEE rate. In our model it brings 36-month TCO at 6,000 accounts to $92,400, against $217,900 for Cronofy, $273,000 for Aurinko and $348,600 for Nylas. Calendar scopes don't need CASA Tier 2. Gmail scopes do.
Nylas vs Cronofy vs Aurinko vs direct OAuth: 2026 architecture and pricing
The real fork in nylas vs cronofy (or cronofy vs nylas) is per-account fees versus building on Google and Microsoft directly. Google Workspace and Microsoft 365 dominate business email and calendar deployments, so Apple CalDAV and on-prem Exchange are edge cases for most B2B products. Over 36 months, four things decide the total: live provider calls versus cached availability, multi-person scheduling, per-account fees, and who holds the OAuth tokens.
1. Nylas v3: architecture, the v2 migration and Nylas pricing
If you last used Nylas on v2, v3 is a different product in three ways:
- Thinner sync model. Nylas v2 mirrored mailboxes inside Nylas storage. Per the platform docs, v3 keeps only about the last 90 days of messages for fast responses and detects changes through webhooks, Google Pub/Sub and Amazon SNS. You call the Nylas Calendar API and Email API and receive Nylas v3 webhooks, while most of the data stays with the provider.
- A breaking migration, and closer contact with provider quotas. v2 was deprecated on December 31, 2024 and reached end of life on January 20, 2025, and moving to v3 grant IDs meant a rewrite. A wrapper didn't save anyone from that. What follows is our engineering judgement, not a vendor statement: bursty availability scans against a provider-first API can still hit upstream
HTTP 429quotas, so most teams end up caching free/busy in their own PostgreSQL anyway. - Nylas pricing. The public plans are Free (5 accounts), Essentials at $15 a month (10 email and calendar accounts, then $2.25 each) and Pro at $49 a month or $43 billed annually (25 accounts, then $2.00 or $1.75 each). Calendar-only accounts are cheaper: $1.70 on Essentials, and $1.50 monthly or $1.35 annual on Pro. Enterprise is quoted in volume bands. A pre-signed HIPAA BAA is available on request on paid plans. A custom auth domain (CNAME) comes with the $2,400 a year Accelerator Package on Pro annual, or with Enterprise. Notetaker bot hours are included in each plan (5, 10 or 70 hours), with overage of $0.80, $0.70 or $0.65 an hour.
2. Cronofy: scheduling engine, Cronofy pricing and data residency
Cronofy never did inbox sync. It's a scheduling and availability API, and that focus shows.
- Multi-person availability. Beyond event CRUD in the Cronofy API, Cronofy handles multi-person and sequenced availability (multi-stage interviews, panels, host pooling, buffers) and ships embeddable UI Elements such as the Availability Viewer.
- Compliance and six data centers. You pick one of six: USA, Canada, UK, Germany (EU), Singapore or Australia. Cronofy holds ISO/IEC 27001 and SOC 2 Type II, supports GDPR, and offers a HIPAA BAA on its US-hosted service, which pairs well with SMART on FHIR clinical scheduling.
- Cronofy pricing. The pricing page lists Emerging at $819 a month (500 synced accounts, then $1.39 each) and Growth at $2,399 a month (3,000 accounts, then $0.69 each), both billed annually. Strategic is a sales conversation, and Cronofy publishes no number for it.
3. Aurinko: the budget option among Nylas alternatives
Aurinko is the one to check if you're shopping Nylas alternatives on price. It normalizes email, calendar, contacts and tasks across Google, Microsoft 365 and Exchange with delta-token sync. Pricing is pay-as-you-go and metered on monthly synced transfer: $1.00 per account a month under 1 GB, $1.50 under 5 GB, and $2.00 unlimited.
4. Direct Google Calendar API sync, Microsoft Graph and what CASA Tier 2 really covers
Why do teams scoping how to build a web app or a real estate chatbot tour scheduler avoid direct OAuth? Usually because of the worries below. Each one is smaller than it sounds.
- Google verification and CASA Tier 2. Calendar scopes such as
calendar.eventsandcalendar.readonlyare sensitive, not restricted. They need OAuth app verification and nothing more. Inbox scopes (gmail.readonly,gmail.modify) are restricted, so they add Google Restricted Scope Verification and an annual App Defense Alliance CASA Tier 2 assessment based on OWASP ASVS. Google puts third-party assessor fees at $500 to $4,500 depending on tier, and the assessor issues a letter of validation. - Webhooks that expire. Google
events.watchchannels last about 7 days by default and send payload-freeX-Goog-Resource-Statepings. Treat the expiration Google returns as the real deadline. Microsoft Graph/subscriptionscap calendar and mail subscriptions at 4,230 minutes, just under 3 days. A BullMQ cron that renews 12 hours beforewebhook_expires_atkeeps both alive. - Delta cursors,
HTTP 410 Goneand recurrence. WhennextSyncTokenor@odata.deltaLinkexpires, Google returnsHTTP 410 Gone(Graph returnssyncStateNotFound). Your worker nullssync_cursorand sweeps a fresh window. In our reference worker that's 30 days back to 365 days ahead on Graph, and 30 days back with no upper bound on Google. It also has to expandRRULE,EXDATEand IANA DST rules per IETF RFC 5545.
Owned calendar sync blueprint: KMS token vault and 410 Gone recovery
In API integration and system integration audits we keep finding the same two bugs in custom calendar sync. The first is raw OAuth refresh tokens stored as plaintext in Postgres, which fails any serious crypto review, CASA Tier 2 included. The second is a worker that crashes when an HTTP 410 Gone response invalidates its stored sync cursor.
PostgreSQL 17 or 18 fixes both (neither feature is version specific) with row-level security in FORCE mode and AWS KMS envelope encryption: GenerateDataKey plus AES-256-GCM, with the tenant bound into the additional authenticated data. These are the decisions our reference design makes:
The 410 path is the part most teams get wrong. When the provider answers 410 Gone, the stored cursor is no longer valid. The worker clears it, sets the calendar status to resyncing, marks the cached events as cancelled, and sweeps a fresh time window. Each page is upserted (skipping rows whose etag is unchanged), then the loop follows the next-page link until the provider returns a new sync token or delta link, which is saved with the status set back to active. Any other non-success response aborts and rolls back the pass.
Events that come back in the fresh sweep are written as not cancelled again, so the window rebuilds itself and only events that really disappeared stay marked. Multi-host availability queries then read a local busy-time index instead of calling a provider, which typically keeps them in single-digit milliseconds.
Nylas vs Cronofy vs Aurinko vs owned sync: 36-month TCO at 6,000 accounts
The model is a multi-tenant B2B product (an ATS, a telehealth app, a vertical CRM) over 36 months with 6,000 active connected accounts, 62% on Google Workspace and 38% on Microsoft 365. It needs two-way free/busy and booking writes, push sync in under 5 seconds, white-label OAuth consent, and SOC 2 Type II, HIPAA BAA and PCI DSS v4.0.1 controls where booking flows collect co-pays.
Labor uses Idealogic's rates: $75 an hour for senior CEE engineers and $165 an hour for a US agency, a 2.2x gap. For labour-cost context, see the EU hourly labour cost dataset (lc_lci_lev) and the US DOL O*NET profile for Software Developers (15-1252.00). Infrastructure uses us-east-1 AWS RDS PostgreSQL and KMS rates. Vendor fees are public list prices, so a negotiated contract may well come in lower.
- Option A: Nylas v3, Pro annual, 6,000 calendar-only accounts
- Setup and ops (760h = $57,000 CEE; $125,400 US): 220h for v3 grant setup, a local free/busy mirror and webhook queues ($16,500 CEE / $36,300 US), plus 15h a month for 36 months, 540h of ops ($40,500 CEE / $89,100 US).
- 36-month subscription ($291,600): $43 + 5,965 x $1.35 = $8,095.75 a month, rounded to $8,100. That's the public calendar-only overage on Pro annual, not a negotiated rate, and Enterprise is quoted. If your accounts also sync email, the same plan runs $43 + 5,975 x $1.75, about $10,499 a month or about $378,000 over 36 months. The Accelerator Package (custom auth domain) adds $2,400 a year and isn't in the total. Total: $348,600 CEE ($417,000 US).
- Option B: Cronofy Growth API plan, 6,000 synced accounts
- Setup and ops (760h = $57,000 CEE; $125,400 US): 220h setup ($16,500 CEE) plus 540h of ops ($40,500 CEE).
- 36-month subscription ($160,884): $2,399 + 3,000 x $0.69 = $4,469 a month at the public Growth price, billed annually. Strategic terms are quoted separately, so treat this as a floor if you need them. Total: $217,884 CEE ($286,284 US).
- Option C: Aurinko, 6,000 accounts on the under 1 GB tier
- Setup and ops (760h = $57,000 CEE; $125,400 US): 220h setup ($16,500 CEE) plus 540h of ops ($40,500 CEE).
- 36-month subscription ($216,000): 6,000 accounts at $1.00 each, $6,000 a month. Total: $273,000 CEE ($341,400 US).
- Option D: Owned Google Workspace + Microsoft Graph sync (KMS vault, BullMQ, CASA Tier 2)
- Turnkey build (560h: $42,000 at $75/hr CEE; $92,400 at $165/hr US): Google and Graph OAuth with PKCE, the FORCE RLS KMS vault, webhook renewal cron, the HTTP 410 Gone worker, RFC 5545 RRULE and DST availability, and CASA Tier 2 hardening.
- 36-month infra and CASA ($18,000, a blended $500 a month): RDS PostgreSQL, Redis for BullMQ and AWS KMS ($350/mo x 36 = $12,600), plus three annual CASA Tier 2 assessments at an assumed $1,800 a year ($5,400). The CASA line only applies if your build also reads Gmail. A calendar-only build skips it, so this total leans conservative.
- 36-month ops (12h/mo x 36 = 432h): $32,400 CEE ($71,280 US). Total: $92,400 CEE ($181,680 US). The CEE total happens to equal the US price of the 560-hour build. They're different sums.
Sensitivity check: startups under 500 accounts, OAuth portability and payback
- Below 500 connected accounts (seed or MVP). Don't build multi-provider sync yourself yet. Start on Aurinko (about $500 a month) or Nylas v3 (about $874 a month for email and calendar on Pro annual), and register your own Google and Microsoft OAuth
client_idcredentials from day one. Do that and a later cutover shouldn't force users to re-consent. - Payback at 6,000 accounts ($75/hr CEE). Option D costs $25,500 more up front ($42,000 minus $16,500) and cuts monthly OpEx from $9,225 (Nylas), $7,125 (Aurinko) and $5,594 (Cronofy) to $1,400. That pays back in 3.26 months against Nylas v3, 4.45 months against Aurinko and 6.08 months against Cronofy.
2026 calendar and inbox sync build costs (senior CEE vs US)
Our custom software development, SaaS development, and software development consulting teams ship sync engines on fixed milestones at $75 an hour senior CEE, against $165 an hour at a US agency (2.2x):
Inside the worked 560-hour owned sync engine ($42,000 CEE vs $92,400 US)
- 1. Watch and Graph push (25%, 140h, $10,500 CEE vs $23,100 US). Google
events.watchand Microsoft Graph/subscriptionsreceivers,clientStatevalidation, the BullMQ renewal cron that fires 12 hours before expiry, and429backoff. - 2. KMS vault on PostgreSQL (25%, 140h, $10,500 CEE vs $23,100 US).
FORCE ROW LEVEL SECURITYschema, AWS KMSGenerateDataKeyenvelope encryption (AES-256-GCMwithAAD), key zeroization in worker memory, and OAuthPKCErevocation. - 3.
RRULEand free/busy (20%, 112h, $8,400 CEE vs $18,480 US).RFC 5545RRULE,EXDATEandRECURRENCE-IDexpansion across IANA DST boundaries, the panel solver, and advisory locks against double booking. - 4. CASA Tier 2 hardening (20%, 112h, $8,400 CEE vs $18,480 US). OWASP ASVS controls, OAuth scope minimization, the Google verification submission, and remediation with the assessor. You only need all of it if you request restricted Gmail scopes.
- 5.
410 Goneand cutover (10%, 56h, $4,200 CEE vs $9,240 US). The self-healingHTTP 410 Gonewindow sweep, OAuth token import without re-consent, and shadow parity checks.
Founders sign per-account calendar wrappers at seed stage to skip Google OAuth verification, then pay six figures a year at Series B and still don't hold their own refresh tokens. First-party OAuth credentials, KMS-encrypted tokens in PostgreSQL, and a CASA Tier 2 assessment where Gmail scopes call for one cut three-year TCO by more than seventy percent against Nylas list pricing in our 6,000-account model.
Nylas vs Cronofy decision checklist: 5 checks for CTOs
Idealogic has shipped regulated scheduling and multi-party workflow systems:
- Clinical schedule sync (AddMed). Bidirectional clinical sync, time-zone windows, and HIPAA/GDPR audit logs.
- PropTech tour booking (Second Floor). Property tour coordination across real estate and PropTech portals.
- Multi-party workflows (Chaindoc). 99.9% uptime multi-actor state machines across 10,000+ signed agreements.
Five checks settle Nylas vs Cronofy vs Aurinko vs owned sync in 2026:
- Under 500 connected accounts? Start on Aurinko or Nylas v3, and bring your own OAuth
client_idcredentials. - Need pre-built scheduling UI elements for ATS panels and a choice of six data centers? Pick Cronofy.
- Need unified email, calendar and tasks under 1,500 accounts? Pick Aurinko at $1.00 per account a month.
- Only writing bookings, never reading full calendars? Use the narrow
calendar.app.createdscope. It needs no CASA assessment, though sensitive-scope verification may still apply. - Scaling from 2,000 to 50,000+ connected accounts? Build owned Google Workspace and Microsoft Graph sync with a KMS vault and BullMQ renewal, and add CASA Tier 2 only if you read Gmail. Contact our team for a 48-hour calendar TCO audit.

Deputy CEO at Idealogic. Overseeing operational execution, product discovery, client partnerships, and engineering squad delivery.
Frequently asked questions
Choose Nylas v3 when your product needs one REST API for email, calendar and contacts across Google Workspace, Microsoft 365 and IMAP, with self-serve onboarding. Choose Cronofy when scheduling is the product: multi-interviewer panel availability, sequenced interviews, embeddable scheduling UI, and a choice of six data centers (USA, Canada, UK, Germany, Singapore, Australia). Cronofy's HIPAA BAA covers its US-hosted service.
Nylas v2 ran a hosted sync engine that mirrored each end user's mailbox and calendar in Nylas storage. Nylas v3 moved to a thinner, provider-first model: it keeps roughly the last 90 days of messages for fast responses and detects changes through webhooks, Google Pub/Sub and Amazon SNS. The move was a breaking migration. v2 was deprecated on December 31, 2024 and reached end of life on January 20, 2025. In our experience v3 also leaves you closer to upstream provider rate limits.
Nylas pricing has a Free plan (5 accounts), Essentials at $15 per month (10 accounts, then $2.25 each) and Pro at $49 per month or $43 billed annually (25 accounts, then $2.00 or $1.75 each). Extra calendar-only accounts cost $1.35 to $1.70 each, and Enterprise is quoted. Cronofy pricing for the API is Emerging at $819 per month (500 synced accounts, then $1.39 each) and Growth at $2,399 per month (3,000 accounts, then $0.69 each), both billed annually, plus a quoted Strategic tier. Aurinko charges from $1.00 per account per month under one gigabyte of transfer.
Not for calendar alone. Google classes Calendar scopes such as calendar.events and calendar.readonly as sensitive, so your app needs OAuth app verification but no security assessment. CASA Tier 2, the annual Cloud Application Security Assessment under the App Defense Alliance, applies to restricted scopes such as gmail.readonly and gmail.modify. If your build also reads Gmail, budget for it: it's an OWASP ASVS based assessment, Google puts third-party assessor fees at $500 to $4,500 depending on tier, and Tier 2 usually takes two to three weeks.
When you call Google Calendar events.list, the final page returns an opaque nextSyncToken cursor for the server state at that moment. Later webhook-triggered syncs pass it as syncToken and get back only changed, created or cancelled events (status='cancelled'). If Google invalidates the token, for example after ACL changes or when the cursor expires, the API returns HTTP 410 Gone. Your worker then has to wipe the stored cursor and run a clean time-window resync.
Neither provider issues permanent webhook subscriptions. Google Calendar events.watch channels expire after about seven days by default (trust the expiration value Google returns), and Microsoft Graph calendar and mail subscriptions max out at 4,230 minutes, just under three days. A production sync engine renews them on a schedule, for example a BullMQ cron that runs twelve hours before webhook_expires_at.
Don't store plaintext OAuth refresh tokens in application tables, and don't rely on disk-level RDS encryption alone. Generate an AES-256-GCM data encryption key per tenant or connection with AWS KMS GenerateDataKey. Store only the KMS-wrapped key next to the ciphertext and authentication tag, in a PostgreSQL 17 or 18 table protected by FORCE ROW LEVEL SECURITY, and decrypt the token only in short-lived worker memory.
At Idealogic's senior Central and Eastern European rate of $75 per hour (versus $165 per hour at US agencies), a single-provider OAuth booking sprint runs $9,000 to $13,500 and a managed Nylas or Cronofy integration costs $13,500 to $19,500. A 560-hour owned Google Workspace plus Microsoft Graph sync engine with KMS envelope encryption, RFC 5545 RRULE expansion and CASA Tier 2 hardening costs $42,000 ($92,400 at US rates). In our 6,000-account model that saves $125,500 to $256,200 over thirty-six months against public vendor list prices.
More from the journal

Paddle vs Lemon Squeezy in 2026: MoR Fees, Stripe & TCO
Paddle vs Lemon Squeezy and Stripe Managed Payments in 2026, compared on fees and 36-month TCO: stacked international and subscription surcharges, merchant of record liability, B2B Net-30 invoicing, PG17 entitlement guards, and the math for a $6M/yr SaaS.

Persona vs Sumsub in 2026: KYC Pricing, PAD & 36-Mo TCO
Engineering and 36-month TCO teardown of Persona vs Sumsub vs Veriff vs Entrust Onfido in 2026: retry and per-service billing terms, ISO/IEC 30107-3 liveness, PG17 FORCE RLS KYC waterfalls, and 20k/mo applicant math.

Lithic vs Marqeta in 2026: Card Issuing, ASA & 36-Mo TCO
Engineering and 36-month TCO teardown of Lithic vs Marqeta vs Stripe Issuing in 2026: direct Visa/Mastercard core vs JIT Gateway, TransactPay UK/EEA EMI, PostgreSQL 17 FORCE RLS multi-capture card ledgers, and $60M/yr interchange math.